I'm having some pretty severe issues trying to upload a second game that I built in the Quest application.

Whenever I go to "Upload Game" no matter what I do it just replaces the file on my existing game. It doesn't give me any options to create it as a new game. I browse the file, hit "Upload" and it just automatically replaces the file on my first game with no further input from me.

I tried creating a new game under "Start Building Your Game Online" but it only opens up the web version of Quest. I tried doing that just to make the listing and then going in under "View/Edit Game Listing" and replacing the game file. It says it uploaded, I return to the game page and nothing has changed, it's still the intro game with just "You are in a room". Do I have to create an entire second account with a different email/login just to be able to upload a second game?

I unfortunately can't share either listing here because, to be perfectly transparent, they are both adult content.

EDIT: Also I just discovered that when I go into "View/Edit Game Listing" for the new game and upload the file there, though I am POSITIVE it's the new listing it's being uploaded to, it still changes the file on the first game.

Sounds like your games have the same ID. It uses the game's ID, rather than the listing ID, to catalogue different games. So if, for example, you copy an existing game and modify it, the site will still know they are the same game.

Look at your game in full code view (or open the ASLX file in Notepad), and look for a line that looks like:

    <gameid>84bd4a21-6d0d-4b3a-b20d-c2e297fc530f</gameid>

It should be pretty close to the top of the file.

I think if you remove this and open the game in the editor, it will automatically generate a new one.
Or you could go to any IFID generator (like this one) and just use the ID that gives you to replace the one in your file.

There is also a button to generate a new ID next to the game ID within the editor. You should find it on the "game" object, two boxes above the Year of release.

Oh fabulous, that worked just fine! That's exactly what was causing the issue and I didn't even realize. Thank you both so much! :D